Best Cookie Tin
Cookie tins aren’t just for the holidays, they can be useful throughout the year. Whether you like keeping cookies in the house but you want to have them in a lovely decorative cookie tin, or you want to purchase a tin that you can add cookies to so you can give someone a special gift, there are a lot of options out there.
Why should you consider using a cookie tin to store your cookies, or to give some yummy treats to your friends and family? Well, when you store your cookies properly, you can help them remain fresh for a longer period of time. No one likes stale cookies, after all! So, investing in at least one good quality tin that you can always have on hand is wise. It can be a great way to help ensure you will be able to keep your favorite homemade treats just right when it comes to how moist and flavorful they are.
Also, here’s a helpful tip: when you store your cookies in a tin, putting a piece of parchment paper or waxed paper in between them is a great idea, especially if they are soft cookies. This simple step can help keep them crisp, and it can also stop them from getting stuck to one another, which is yet another thing that no one likes.
If you are ready to shop for a cookie tin that you can use for yourself or give away, but you don’t know where to begin or what you should look for, check out our list below to get started.
Best Colorful Cookie Tin: Cornucopia Cookie Tins
These eye-catching cookie tins are great for everyday use, feature a contemporary design, and can add a lot of color to your day. They come in a set of two, so you can use both at the same time, switch between them as you see fit, or keep one and give one away as a gift.
Measuring 3.6” tall and 7.75” in diameter, with an interior that measures 3.25” x 7.25”, these cookie tins provide you with plenty of space for keeping a variety of cookies fresh. They weigh around 9 ounces when they are empty, have a capacity of 2.3 quarts, and are made of food grade steel with a tin coating.
Pros:
- This is a set of two cookie tins—one features a rainbow stripe design and the other features a blue/purple solid color design.
- The large capacity can hold a lot of small cookies or several big cookies.
- Contemporary, colorful design can fit right in with your kitchen’s design scheme, adding a fun element to the space.
Cons:
- You can’t put these in your dishwasher or in your microwave, and they should only be hand washed and dried immediately.
Best Nesting Cookie Tin Set: Juvale Nesting Tins Set
If you would like a set of cookie tins that feature an eye-catching, modern design, definitely check out the Juvale Nesting Tins Set. You get a total of three lovely cookie tins, each a different size, and when you need to store them away, they fit neatly into each other.
What’s nice about this set is that you can use each tin for a different purpose. For example, you might store large cookies in the biggest tin, and keep your smallest cookies, such as bite-sized cookies, in the smallest tin, so you know exactly where your favorite treats are. The small tin measures 5.5” x 5.5” x 2.9”, while the medium one measures 6.7” x 6.7” x 3.2” and the large one measures 7.8” x 7.8” x 3.5”.
These cookie tins are made of strong and sturdy, yet lightweight, tin material. They feature a gold and white marble design, but they are available in a black and gold version as well. And we also like that you can stack these cookie tins to make an attractive display for everyday use or when you are entertaining.
Pros:
- These cookie tins feature an attractive white and gold marble design, perfect for gifting or to add an attractive element to your kitchen.
- This set comes with three tins of varying sizes, providing you with multiple options and plenty of versatility.
- These tins are stackable and nesting.
Cons:
- Some reviewers complain that the price for these tins is too high.
Best Stackable Cookie Tins: StarPack Premium Christmas Cookie Tins Set of 3
Another set of three stackable and nesting cookie tins is this one from StarPack, which features a beautiful red and white floral design that can be perfect for everyday use and for holiday use.
These round cookie tins have a snap closure and come in three sizes: the large one measures roughly 8” in diameter, the medium measures about 6.8” in diameter, and the small one measures around 5.7” in diameter. Choose what you want to store in each one for easy access to your favorite treats!
We also like that these are made of steel that is thicker, so they are designed to be more durable. Plus, the materials used are food grade and BPA free as well. When cared for properly, they can last a long time. And when you need to store them away, just wipe them under some hot water to clean them before drying them thoroughly and nesting them for compact storage.
Pros:
- This set of cookie tins provides you with three tins of varying sizes to suit all of your needs.
- These cookie tins feature a modern, attractive design.
- When not in use, you can store them conveniently, thanks to the nesting design.
- These tins are built to be durable and long-lasting, thanks to the thicker steel that is used to make them.
Cons:
- Some customers who reviewed this product state that the tins are smaller than they thought they’d be.
Best Decorative Cookie Tin: Premium Cookie Tins with Lids
Yet another attractive option when you are on the hunt for round cookie tins is this set of two, which feature a gold base with a black lid that boasts an eye-catching print. These measure roughly 7-3/16” x 2-5/8”, and they are both the same size, so you can choose to keep and use both or keep one and give the other one away as a gift to someone you care about.
We like that these tins can be used on a day-to-day basis, but they can also be displayed during the holidays and other special occasions. They will hold plenty of cookies, helping to keep them fresh for as long as possible.
Also, because you get two tins for an affordable price, you can always have a tin available when you need it, or if you bake a lot of cookies, you can rest assured that you will have plenty of storage space for all of them. And if you make two different types of cookies at the same time, each type can be stored in its own tin so you don’t end up mixing cookies that shouldn’t be stored together.
Pros:
- This is a set of two cookie tins that are the same size.
- These tins feature an attractive and modern design in black and gold.
- These are a good size for storing a lot of cookies.
Cons:
- The design might not appeal to all people.
- These are not nesting, so they do take up more space when you need to store them away in between uses.
Best Large Cookie Tin: Zelica Premium Large Holiday Cookie & Candy Tin
Do you need a large cookie tin, but you want it to also have a unique appearance that is different from the many other tins that are available? Then it is worth checking out this large holiday cookie and candy tin, which measures 6.5” x 7” and is made in the shape of a little bucket, complete with a cute handle.
Like the other tins on this list, this one can make a wonderful gift or it can serve as a nice decorative element in your home. The colorful design is sure to grab the attention of your guests, and it is appropriate for both everyday use and special occasions, whether you are hosting a birthday party, summer get-together, or anything in between.
One thing to consider: this is a deep cookie tin, so that is something to think about when it comes to storing your cookies, as it may not work well for all types of cookies because of its shape.
Pros:
- This is a large cookie tin in the shape of a cylinder with a handle that makes it easy to carry.
- This cookie tin features a colorful and fun design.
Cons:
- The deep design might not work well for all types of cookies.
Best Cookie Tin for Gifting: Decorae Cookie Tins
Last on our list of high-quality cookie tins is this set from Decorae. You get two round cookie tins that are made of food grade, tin-coated steel. Each one has a capacity of 2.3 quarts. Also, they measure 7.75” x 3.6”, with interior dimensions that are 7.25” x 3.25”, so they provide plenty of space for your goodies.
These cookie tins are the same size, but each one has its own unique design, and they pair perfectly together. So, whether you want to give these away as a gift that is filled with delectable treats or you want them for yourself, they’re sure to impress.
One of the tins is white and features the saying, “Bake the World a Better Place.” The other tin is black and features the words, “Sweet Friendships Refresh the Soul.” So, as you can see, they really can make a wonderful gift for a friend!
Pros:
- These tins weigh 9 ounces each and are a nice size for a good amount of cookies.
- These feature a basic, modern look with positive phrases written on their lids, so they can be used to add an attractive element to your kitchen’s design scheme.
- These are made of food grade steel with tin coating.
Cons:
- These should not be placed in the microwave or the dishwasher.
- Some customers found that the tins are too thin.
Things to look out for:
When looking for the right cookie tin, consider more than just the design. Sure, you will likely want to go with a decorative tin, but there are some other things to think about, too, and they include the following:
First off, consider the size of the cookie tin that you need. Do you want a little one just to keep a few cookies in every now and then, or do you want to go with a large one that will be able to hold a lot of different cookies? Also, remember to consider depth, too, as the deeper the tin, the more space you will have, even if it isn’t all that wide.
Getting more than one container is a great idea because it isn’t always wise to combine different types of cookies, even though a cookie tin that is filled with a variety of flavors can be enticing and lovely to look at. For example, it’s recommended that you keep crisp cookies in their own tin, separate from soft cookies, so that each type maintains the proper texture.
Cookie tins come in a variety of shapes, too. Going with a square or rectangular cookie tin can be a good option when you do want to combine different types of cookies in the same space. If you can’t find a cookie tin that has dividers in place already, you can use a material like corrugated paper to line the tin and create sections into which you can add cookies for a beautiful presentation.
Finally, in terms of material, you will find cookie tins that are made of plastic, but it is usually better to go with a metal tin, as this type of material can help ensure your cookies will remain firm for longer.
Photo credit: Joan Carles Juarez/Shutterstock