Do you enjoy eating roasted meals that feature a variety of delicious and nutritious ingredients? Then it is worth investing in a high-quality roaster pan that you can use whenever you want to prepare a wide range of recipes for yourself and your family.
While this might not be a kitchen tool that you use every day, or even every week for that matter, it is something that you will want to have on hand. Whether you are planning on hosting the holidays, a get-together with friends, or a party at home with your family, when you need to cook up large meals that are full of flavor, you will be glad you had a good roaster pan at the ready.
What about just sticking with disposable roaster pans? Well, this isn’t really the most budget-friendly or most convenient idea. Firstly, you will need to continue buying them after you use them. On the other hand, if you buy a single good quality roaster pan, you can use it again and again, thereby saving more money in the long run. Secondly, those disposable pans often aren’t strong enough for heavy ingredients. On the other hand, a sturdy roaster pan made of a durable material, such as carbon steel, can ensure you won’t end up with messes in your kitchen and oven or burns to your skin.
There are a lot of roaster pans that you can choose from, but selecting the right one is important to get the best possible results. To help you start your search, we have compiled a list of six roaster pans that are certainly worth your consideration, and you can also access some helpful shopping tips below.
Best Non-Stick Roaster Pan: DaTerra Cucina Ceramic Coated Roasting Pan
This rectangular roaster pan is made in Italy by the brand DaTerra Cucina. It is a professional-grade product that boasts a ceramic coating and aluminum base to help ensure all of your ingredients will be cooked evenly, thanks to great heat distribution.
What we also like about this roaster pan is the fact that it is resistant to scratches, which is definitely helpful when it comes to durability. And this product also helps you reduce your need for oil because of its non-stick surface, so if you have been hoping to limit the amount of oil in your diet, this may be the right choice for you.
This roaster pan is safe to use in your oven to cook up a wide range of ingredients. It is cadmium-free, lead-free, PFOA-free, and PTFE-free. And the aluminum is recyclable too, making it an eco-friendly option.
Pros:
- It comes with a 1-year warranty that allows you to return it if you aren’t happy with it.
- It features a non-stick, ceramic material that allows for even heat distribution.
- It has a heavy-duty aluminum base that will heat up quickly.
Cons:
- It does not have handles.
- It might be too shallow for some ingredients.
Best Multi-Piece Set: Cook Pro 4-Piece All-in-1 Lasagna and Roasting Pan
For an affordable price, this 4-piece set from Cook Pro gives you a lot. You get two pans that can be used to cook up a variety of meals for your whole family because you can select from the smaller roaster pan, which measures 12.5” x 9.5” x 2.25”, or the larger one that measures 16.5” x 12” x 2.5”.
These oven-safe roaster pans are made of stainless steel and are resistant to corrosion and rust. And they are rectangular in shape, so they have plenty of room to cook everything from lasagna to starchy vegetables.
Plus, the exterior of these pans is mirror polished to make them more attractive, so they can also be used as serving dishes if you wish. And the stainless handles are there to help ensure you can safely and easily lift, carry, and place these pans into the oven.
One last feature that we really like about this set: it is dishwasher safe to make cleanup a snap—perfect for anyone who hates washing roaster pans by hand.
Pros:
- You get two pans for the price of one.
- They feature handles and come with chrome racks.
- They are made of durable stainless steel.
- They are easy to clean.
Cons:
- The handles fold down, so they might be a little difficult to grab when taking these roaster pans out of the oven.
- Some reviewers complain of staining and difficulty cleaning because these roaster pans aren’t non-stick.
Best Budget: CasaWare Ceramic Coated NonStick Lasagna/Roaster Pan
Are you searching for a budget-friendly, lightweight, rectangular, non-stick roaster pan? Well, this one checks off all of those boxes, and more. Weighing just 1.54 pounds, this ceramic coated roaster pan is made of carbon steel. It is available in several color options, such as blue granite, red granite, rose gold granite, and silver granite, so you can choose the one that you like best or buy more than one so you have different colors to use for different occasions.
This roaster pan measures 13” x 10” x 3”, and it is PTFE free, aluminum free, lead free, cadmium free, PFOA free, and PFOS free. The ceramic coating is FDA approved and European Union approved, as well as approved by California Proposition 65.
The baking surface of this pan allows for easy release of ingredients when they are ready to be served. And when it comes to cleaning, it’s a snap to wash this product by hand because the food slides off so easily.
Pros:
- It features a ceramic surface and carbon steel for ease of use, scratch resistance, and durability.
- It is heat tolerant to avoid blistering and peeling.
- It comes in several attractive colors.
Cons:
- Hand washing is recommended, so this might not be the right choice if you want something that will be dishwasher safe.
- Depending on what you’re planning on cooking in it, this pan might be too small and light.
Best Oval Roaster Pan: GoldenPlayer Enamel Oval Turkey Roasting Pan with Lid
If you would prefer an oval shaped roaster pan rather than one that is rectangular, it is worth checking out this option, which is affordably priced and designed to meet your needs when cooking various recipes in the oven.
This roaster pan, which comes with a lid, measures 14.6” x 10.5” x 5”, so you can cook up a variety of ingredients in it. And because it is made of solid carbon steel and features a porcelain finish, it can absorb and distribute heat evenly as well, thus helping your ingredients cook quickly and efficiently. Compared to roaster pans that are made of glass or steel, you might find that you are able to cook your recipes in a shorter amount of time with this product. Who wouldn’t love that?
Another neat feature: the lid of this non-stick roaster pan features self-basting bumps, which help to direct moisture downward so your ingredients can be juicy and moist rather than dry and flavorless. Plus, this product is dishwasher safe for ease of cleaning, and it is free of chemicals like PFOA and PTFE.
Pros:
- It is designed to be durable and long-lasting.
- It is dishwasher safe so it is easy to clean.
- It is oval and comes with a lid, so it can be a good alternative to rectangular roaster pans.
Cons:
- The handles on the sides might be too small to easily move this roaster pan out of the oven.
Best Basic Roasting Pan: Mydracas Non-Stick Roasting Pan
When you are ready to add a basic roaster pan to your collection of kitchen tools, this pan from Mydracas is a good option to consider. It features a combination of premium carbon steel and a non-stick surface, so it is designed to be long-lasting and durable, as well as easy to use and clean.
If you want to cook your ingredients evenly and quickly, this large roaster pan, which measures 16.75” x 10.75” x 1.75”, can do the trick. And, when your meal is ready, the non-stick surface will help ensure everything comes out easily without sticking to the pan and creating a mess. Then, when it comes to cleaning this roaster pan, you can just put it in your dishwasher or wash it easily by hand.
Pros:
- It features carbon steel for fast and even heat distribution, no matter what ingredients you’re cooking.
- It has a non-stick surface that helps ensure your ingredients will release easily, and this also helps make it easy to keep the pan clean.
- It is large enough to fit a lot of different ingredients of varying sizes.
Cons:
- Although it is dishwasher safe, hand washing this roaster pan is recommended.
Best Stainless Steel Roaster Pan: Ovente Kitchen Oval Roasting Pan
Last on our list is this oval stainless steel roaster pan that comes with a convenient lid. It weighs 3.5 pounds and measures 16 inches, so it can hold a lot of ingredients that you want to roast efficiently.
The nice thing about this roaster pan is that the stainless steel is designed to withstand high heat, and it will be able to maintain both its form and its finish without warping, corroding, rusting, or bending.
Pros:
- It is made of premium stainless steel for durability and attractiveness.
- It is designed to be long-lasting and resistant to rusting and warping.
- It comes with a rack and a lid, and it also has handles.
Cons:
- It is recommended that you wash it by hand with mild detergent and a soft sponge.
Things to look out for:
When shopping for a good quality roaster pan, we recommend keeping the following things in mind so you can rest assured that you will make the right choice for your needs:
You can find roaster pans with racks that can securely hold your ingredients so they remain above any drippings while they cook. Plus, this is an option to consider when you want to ensure your ingredients will cook as evenly as possible too.
Roaster pans that are heavyweight are often preferable, but you want to be sure that you’ll be able to carry this type of pan easily, so it’s a great idea to check the weight of a product before you buy it. After all, you don’t want to hurt yourself or risk spilling everything!
Also be sure to consider the size of the pan. If you are planning on cooking a lot of ingredients with this handy tool, you will definitely want to be sure that all of them will fit inside the pan. Other times, though, a lightweight pan that is small and shallow might be just what you need. For example, when you want to cook fewer ingredients that won’t fill up a large roaster pan, it is a great idea to go with a smaller pan, as this will help ensure the juices from the ingredients won’t end up burning from being in an oversized pan. For these reasons, you might want to buy a few roaster pans of varying sizes and depths just to be sure you always have what you need.
Generally, a shallow pan can be a good way to go if you want to be able to easily stir ingredients as they cook, and if you want crispy results—yum! However, a deep roaster pan can be useful when you have a lot of large ingredients that need to be cooked at the same time.
You also want to be sure your roaster pan is made of a material that will conduct heat really well and be able to withstand high temperatures (it is going into your oven after all). Recommended options include carbon steel, stainless steel, and aluminum.
Finally, a product with handles is certainly going to make it easier to move your roaster pan around, especially when sliding it into and out of a hot oven, so this extra feature is always a plus.
Photo credit: rlat/Shutterstock