Delicious cupcakes and muffins are hard to resist, and they are also surprisingly easy to make right at home. But in order to get the best results (muffins that are soft and moist and not burnt), you need to have the right tins on hand.
Muffin tins are affordable, so you can buy more than one to have available whenever you want to bake some sweet treats for your family and friends. But because there are so many options available on the market these days, you might start to feel a little overwhelmed once you start shopping. Should you go with a muffin tin that has silicone grips or you should just go with a 100% silicone tin? Do you bake up a lot of muffins at once or can you get by with just one tin that holds 12 cups? And do you prefer jumbo muffins, mini muffins, or standard size muffins?
By answering all of the questions above, you can start to narrow down your options to those that you would use most often. But if you still want some help when it comes to choosing the right muffin tin, check out the list of products we’ve compiled below.
1. Top Pick: Wilton Perfect Results Premium Non-Stick Bakeware Standard Muffin and Cupcake Pan
Nonstick products are so popular because they can make things a lot easier when it comes to cleaning your bakeware. Plus, if you have ever experienced the hassle of a cake or other dessert sticking to a pan, you know how helpful a high-quality nonstick coating can be. That’s why we’re including this nonstick standard muffin and cupcake pan on our list of recommendations.
With this muffin pan, you can bake 12 muffins or cupcakes at a time. It is made of durable steel that helps ensure heat will be distributed evenly while your muffins bake. And this pan is also resistant to warping over time as well.
Also, when it comes to releasing your baked treats and cleaning your muffin pan, the nonstick coating on this item will make it all quick and easy. Plus, this product is dishwasher safe.
Pros:
- This muffin pan is made of durable materials and has a nonstick coating that is scratch-resistant.
- This muffin pan is dishwasher safe.
- You can bake 12 muffins or cupcakes at once in this pan.
Cons:
- Some customer reviews state the nonstick coating could be better.
2. Best Silicone Muffin Tin: KPKitchen Silicone Muffin Pan
In the same way that you can find silicone baking products for cakes, breads, and pies, you can also find muffin tins that are made of silicone. This can be a good alternative to traditional metal bakeware. And if you are interested in trying a silicone muffin tin, this particular one might be a good option to start with.
This tin can bake up to 12 muffins at once, and it is made of European LFGB grade silicone that is BPA free. It also does not contain any plastic fillers or additives, and it passes the pinch test. Plus, whenever you need to clean this muffin tin, you can put it in your dishwasher to keep things simple.
This muffin tin is nonstick, so you should find it easy to pop your muffins or cupcakes out of the cups when they are done baking and cooling. But what’s also nice about this muffin tin is that it comes with 24 paper muffin liners, so you can start using this product right away when you get it.
Pros:
- This silicone muffin tin is heat resistant up to 450°F, and it is microwave, freezer, and dishwasher safe.
- This muffin tin is nonstick and holds 12 cups, and it comes with paper liners.
- This product is made of 100% silicone and is free of BPA and additives, and fillers.
Cons:
- For better stability, this silicone muffin tin should be placed on a cookie sheet when you put it in the oven.
3. Best Ceramic Muffin Tin: casaWare Toaster Oven 6 Cup Muffin Pan
Another popular material in the world of bakeware is ceramic, and this muffin tin from casaWare is a good option to consider if this is the type of material that you would prefer. Available in various colors, such as blue granite, red granite, rose gold granite, and silver granite, this muffin tin is stylish and has several attractive features.
We like that this muffin tin is durable and features a nonstick coating that makes it easy to release your muffins and cupcakes. Plus, this product is PTFE free, lead free, cadmium free, PFOS free, and PFOA free. And the coating that’s used is European Union, FDA, and California Proposition 65 approved. Nice, right?
One thing to keep in mind is that you can only bake up six muffins or cupcakes at a time with this tin, so if you want to do more than that to save time, you would need to buy more than one of these tins, and the cost could quickly add up. But this product is heat tolerant to 450°F, and it’s built to be durable and scratch-resistant, so you might find that it’s worth the cost.
Pros:
- This ceramic muffin tin is nonstick and features a double coated ceramic surface over carbon steel.
- This muffin tin is free of lead, cadmium, PTFE, PFOS, and PFOA.
- You can fit this muffin pan in a conventional oven or a toaster oven.
Cons:
- This muffin tin only holds six cups.
- This product is not microwave safe.
- Because hand washing is recommended, it isn’t a good idea to put this muffin tin in your dishwasher.
4. Best Muffin Tin Set: Joho Baking Nonstick Muffin Pan
Sometimes, you’re in the mood for regular size muffins, but other times, you might prefer mini muffins. Why not buy a set of muffin tins that will allow you to have it all, rather than needing to decide between one or the other? With this set of two muffin tins, you get one that holds 12 cups of standard muffins and another that holds 24 cups of mini muffins.
These muffin tins, which are made of heavy gauge carbon steel, feature nonstick technology to make them easy to use and clean. They are designed to distribute heat evenly so every muffin or cupcake will come out just right. And the wide handles also help when you need to get a good grip to move these into and out of your oven.
What’s also nice is that these tins are stackable, so you can save space when you are storing them in between uses. And they are also designed to resist rust, warping, and scratches, so they might last a long time.
Pros:
- This set of muffin tins gives you two different sizes: standard and mini.
- These muffin tins feature a nonstick coating and wide handles, and they are built to be durable and warp-resistant.
- You can stack these muffin tins to save storage space.
Cons:
- Hand washing is recommended for these muffin tins, so they aren’t right for you if you want something that will be dishwasher safe.
5. Best Jumbo Muffin Tin: OvenStuff Non-Stick 6 Cup Jumbo Muffin Pan
Do you ever crave a delicious and soft jumbo muffin? Well, with this muffin tin from OvenStuff, you can make a batch of big muffins right at home whenever the craving hits.
This pan only holds six cups, so if you think you will want to make many more muffins during the same baking session, just be sure to buy more than one tin—they are affordably priced, which is certainly a plus if you want to stock up.
We like that this muffin tin features a nonstick coating that keeps things simple when it comes to food release and cleaning. Also, it is PFOA free and made in the USA. And it is made from steel that is strong and able to heat evenly to help prevent unwanted hot spots during baking.
Pros:
- This jumbo muffin tin bakes up muffins and cupcakes that are 3.5” in diameter.
- Thanks to the durable materials and nonstick coating, this muffin tin is designed to be easy to use and long-lasting.
- This muffin tin is PFOA free.
Cons:
- Hand washing is recommended for this muffin tin, so you should not put it in your dishwasher when you need to clean it.
- Some customer reviews complain about rust developing on this muffin tin, so care should be taken to ensure it is washed and dried properly.
6. Best Colorful Muffin Tin: Farberware purECOok Hybrid Ceramic Nonstick 12-Cup Muffin Tin
Want to add a bit of color to your bakeware collection? Then check out this muffin tin from Farberware, which is available in pretty colors like aqua and lavender. This tin can hold 12 cups so you can bake a bunch of cupcakes and muffins quickly. And you can feel good about using this product because it is PTFE free and PFOA free.
This muffin tin features a hybrid ceramic nonstick coating throughout, so your muffins should release easily, and this tin should also be super easy to clean. Plus, this tin is resistant to warping, so if you take care of it, it can last a long time.
Other nice features include: the wide handles that make it easy to get a good grip on this muffin tin, the fact that it is oven safe up to a whopping 500°F, and the quilted surface that provides airflow and stability to help you achieve the tastiest results.
Pros:
- This hybrid ceramic nonstick muffin tin boasts steel construction that is resistant to warping.
- This product has wide handles that make it easy to carry.
- This muffin tin has a quilted surface to help you achieve better baking results.
- This muffin tin is PTFE and PFOA free.
Cons:
- This muffin tin should only be washed by hand, not in a dishwasher.
7. Best Muffin Tin with Silicone Handles: Amazon Basics Non-Stick 12-Cup Muffin Pan
Do you tend to have trouble gripping bakeware, including muffin tins? Then buying products that feature wide handles with silicone grips can be a smart way to go. After all, whenever you’re placing muffin tins into a hot oven or carrying them to your counter when you remove them from the oven, you want to be sure you’ll have a solid grip to prevent messes and burns.
This 12-cup muffin tin from Amazon Basics is one of several muffin tins that are available with a silicone grip on the handles. It is made of carbon steel that is BPA free, it is oven safe to 428°F, and it also has a nonstick coating. Therefore, in addition to being durable and reliable, it is also easy to use when releasing your muffins or cupcakes and when cleaning the tin after use.
Pros:
- This muffin tin is made of strong carbon steel and has a nonstick coating.
- This muffin tin is BPA free.
- The silicone on the handles makes it easier to grip and carry this muffin tin.
Cons:
- This muffin tin should be washed by hand, so it isn’t a good option if you really want something that you can pop into your dishwasher.
8. Best Muffin Tin with Lid: Anolon Advanced Nonstick 12-Cup Muffin Tin With Silicone Grips and Lid
By using a lid, you can more easily transport your freshly baked muffins or cupcakes if you are taking them with you to a holiday gathering or other event, and it can also help you keep them fresh for longer at home. That’s why we have included this muffin tin from Anolon, as it comes with a lid that fits it just right.
This muffin tin features heavy-duty construction, and it is designed to distribute heat evenly and resist warping. It also has a medium color tone that is designed to help brown your muffins perfectly. Plus, it has a convenient nonstick coating on the inside and outside to make it simple to release your muffins and thoroughly clean the pan when you are done using it.
Another really nice feature is the wide rim, which has a silicone grip. If you tend to have trouble carrying muffin tins, especially when wearing thick oven mitts, this design might help make things easier on you. And you can choose from gray or bronze colors to suit your preferences.
Pros:
- This muffin tin comes with a clear lid that is sturdy and made of plastic. You can use it to protect your muffins during transport or to keep them fresher for longer.
- This tin is oven safe to 450°F, so you can make a variety of muffin and cupcake recipes with it.
- This muffin tin has a nonstick coating, and it is made from steel, so it is built to be durable and warp-resistant.
Cons:
- This muffin tin is on the pricier end compared to others on the market.
Things to look out for:
When you are shopping for a high-quality muffin tin, there are some things to consider to ensure you make the right choice. After all, with so many different products on the market, it can be hard to figure out which ones are worth their price. Here are a few things we recommend thinking about as you browse your options:
First, consider the material that you want the muffin tin to be made of. Do you prefer a regular nonstick tin that is made of metal, or do you want to go with something that is made of ceramic or silicone instead? No matter what, check the product details to be sure it is not made with any unwanted chemicals.
Another thing to think about is the size of the muffin tin in terms of how many cups it holds. Some muffin tins only have six cups, while others have 12. Also, the size of the cups can vary, from mini muffins to jumbo muffins. Depending on what you prefer, and how much you bake, you might decide to stock your kitchen with muffin tins featuring these different sizes. And, whether you go with a 12-cup or 6-cup muffin tin, you might want to go ahead and buy more than one so you can bake up large batches while saving time.
Finally, think about whether you want your muffin tin to come with any accessories, such as a lid that will make transporting the muffins and keeping them fresh a lot easier.
Photo credit: Elena Veselova/Shutterstock