Best Cookie Sheet
With a good quality cookie sheet, you can bake up a variety of yummy cookies that you can snack on, take to holiday gatherings and parties, and give away to friends and family to make them feel special.
There are a lot of different cookie sheets that you can choose from, but they aren’t all created equal. Once you start looking for one of these baking essentials, you might start to feel confused about which one is right for you. Should you get the aluminum one, the nonstick one, or the one that comes with accessories like a handy cookie rack, for example? Or, would a ceramic or stainless steel cookie sheet be right for you? It’s a lot!
To help you see some of the pros and cons of all of these options in the world of cookie sheets, we have compiled a list of eight items that we recommend checking out when you are ready to shop. No matter which one you go with, or how many you buy, the most important thing is that this product allows you to bake delicious treats with ease.
1. Top Pick: Circulon Nonstick Bakeware
Nonstick cookware and bakeware helps make the whole process of preparing a wide range of recipes a breeze. When it comes to cookie sheets, in particular, not only does this type of coating make it easy to release the cookies that you baked, but it also helps make it simple to clean the sheet thoroughly before storing it away until you need it again.
This nonstick cookie sheet from Circulon measures 11” x 17”, so it’s a good size for making a big batch of yummy cookies. It is designed to be long-lasting, thanks to its heavy gauge steel, and it is also resistant to warping. Plus, it is oven safe to 450°F, giving you plenty of freedom to try a variety of recipes.
In addition to all of that, this cookie sheet has wide handles, which is a plus if you tend to struggle with getting a good grip on hot bakeware as you are taking it out of the oven. And we also like that this cookie sheet is dishwasher safe, even though hand washing is recommended.
Finally, this sheet has a high-low circle design that helps ensure your cookies bake to perfection and will release easily without sticking. This feature combines with the nonstick coating that can also help with food release and ease of cleanup.
Pros:
- This cookie sheet is built to last, and it has a convenient nonstick coating.
- The wide handles on this cookie sheet make it easy to grab and move it into and out of a hot oven.
- This cookie sheet is PFOA free, lead free, and cadmium free.
Cons:
- Although this product is dishwasher safe, it is best to hand wash it to help ensure the nonstick coating will last.
2. Best Aluminum Cookie Sheet: AirBake Natural Aluminum 2 Pack Insulated Cookie Sheet
Another material you can consider trying when you are searching for a cookie sheet is aluminum, and this product from AirBake is one example of that type of bakeware. It is dishwasher safe, which is certainly a plus because it means you won’t need to always wash it by hand. And this set provides you with a medium and a large cookie sheet.
This product can even help reduce the amount of baking time needed by up to 15%, thanks to the insulated sheets and micro-dome technology—which means you can enjoy your sweet treats even sooner! And we also like that this 100% aluminum cookie sheet will not rust. Plus, its air insulation helps prevent your ingredients from burning while they bake in your oven.
Pros:
- This cookie sheet is made of 100% aluminum and can help prevent your cookies from burning.
- This bakeware is dishwasher safe for ease of cleaning.
- This is a set of two cookie sheets that can help reduce the amount of time it takes to bake your favorite cookies.
Cons:
- Before you use this cookie sheet, you’ll need to wash it and condition it with oil.
- You need to take care to avoid overheating this cookie sheet, and you should only use plastic utensils on it.
- This cookie sheet isn’t watertight, so care needs to be taken to ensure water doesn’t get and stay inside its two sheets.
3. Best Cookie Sheet with Rack: Wildone Baking Sheet & Rack Set
Taking your cookies off a baking sheet and allowing them to cool on a rack is recommended, but instead of buying these two items separately, you can get them together when you purchase this product. Plus, with this set, you actually get four pieces because you get two cookie sheets and two racks for an affordable price.
These baking sheets and cooling racks are made of durable stainless steel, and they do not have any chemical coatings. Plus, they are resistant to rust, and display a lovely mirror finish that looks good and helps prevent your cookies from sticking. Plus, the deep sides help prevent messes.
We also like that both the cookie sheet and rack are dishwasher safe, making them super easy to clean. And the edges of the sheet make it easy to hold while you clean it, as well as when you move it into and out of an oven.
Pros:
- This is a set that gives you two cookie sheets and two matching cooling racks.
- The cookie sheet is designed to be easy to hold and simple to clean because it’s dishwasher safe.
- These products are made of high-quality, sturdy, and durable 18/10 stainless steel.
Cons:
- Some customer reviews complain of warping after using this cookie sheet.
4. Best Ceramic Cookie Sheet: Farberware Ceramic Nonstick Bakeware
Ceramic bakeware is really popular because it can serve as a good alternative to traditional nonstick products. This option from Farberware can be something to consider if you want to take this route with your next cookie sheet. You can choose from two sizes, which are 10” x 15” and 11” x 17”, and you can add a nice touch of color to your bakeware collection at home because this cookie sheet features a pretty shade of aqua.
We like that this cookie sheet is PTFE and PFOA free. It features ceramic nonstick all over its surface so you can enjoy easy food release and quick cleanup. You can also expect that the steel construction will help ensure this cookie sheet will be durable and long-lasting, as well as resistant to warping. Plus, this cookie sheet promotes even browning because it has a quilted surface that helps increase airflow and improve stability while in the oven.
Pros:
- This is a ceramic nonstick cookie sheet with a quilted surface design that promotes even baking and makes food release and cleanup a snap.
- This cookie sheet can withstand oven temperatures up to 500°F.
- The wide handles on this cookie sheet help make it easier to grip, even when you’re wearing oven mitts.
Cons:
- This cookie sheet is not dishwasher safe and should be hand washed only.
5. Best Commercial Grade Cookie Sheet: Doughmakers Grand Cookie Sheet Commercial Grade Aluminum Bake Pan 14 x 17.5
If you take your baking seriously, or you just want to use the highest quality products that professionals use, check out this commercial grade cookie sheet that is made of 100% aluminum.
This item boasts a pebble pattern that is patented, and it works by letting air flow under your cookies to promote even browning. And when your cookies are cool and you are ready to remove them from this pan, you can also do so easily with the help of this sheet’s nonstick properties.
Compared to aluminized steel and other nonstick cookie sheets, this one is more rust resistant and more durable. And if you scratch it by accident, you don’t need to worry about that having an impact on this product’s performance.
Pros:
- This cookie sheet is made of commercial 18 gauge aluminum.
- It features a pebble pattern that helps ensure great baking results and also makes it easy to release your cookies once they’ve cooled.
- This product helps remove the need for oils, sprays, and shortenings because it is naturally nonstick, so your recipes can be a bit healthier.
Cons:
- In order to keep this cookie sheet in the best shape possible, it is best to wash it right away by hand after use.
- Some reviewers complain that this cookie sheet is flimsy.
6. Best Stainless Steel Cookie Sheet: Suwimut Baking Sheet Set of 4
One of the many materials that you can consider trying when you want to add a new cookie sheet to your bakeware collection is stainless steel. This set of four gives you various sizes that you can use when you are baking up small to large batches of cookies. Plus, you can also use these cookie sheets for other recipes that you prepare in your oven or toaster oven!
These durable cookie sheets are made of strong stainless steel and feature a smooth mirror finish, and they do not have any chemical coatings. So, if you are looking for a product that is basic in terms of the materials that it is made of, this is a good option to consider. Also, these are resistant to rust, they have deep sides to help prevent messes, and they are dishwasher safe to be super easy to clean.
Pros:
- This is a set of four cookie sheets, ranging from small to large. Each sheet is a different size.
- These cookie sheets are made of stainless steel that is resistant to rust, and they do not have any chemical coatings.
- These cookie sheets are dishwasher safe.
Cons:
- If you prefer a product that has a nonstick coating, this type of cookie sheet may not be right for you.
- You only get one of each size. Therefore, if you need, for example, two large cookie sheets, you would need to buy two sets.
7. Best Cookie Sheet Set: Anolon Gourmet Nonstick Bakeware Set with Nonstick Cookie Sheets / Baking Sheets
Getting a cookie sheet set is a great way to spend money one time so you don’t need to worry about having to buy multiple cookie sheets separately. This might help you save money, and it can certainly be a time-saving strategy. A great example is this set from Anolon, which is available in multiple colors like bronze brown and graphite gray.
With this set, you get three cookie sheets that are oven safe up to 450°F, and each one is a different size. So, whether you need a small, medium, or large cookie sheet for your next baking session, this set has you covered. And you’ll also like that these cookie sheets are made of durable steel and have a PFOA-free nonstick coating to make food release and cleanup simple and fast.
Pros:
- These cookie sheets are made of durable heavy-gauge steel, and they resist warping.
- This cookie sheet set gives you three different sizes, which are 11” x 17”, 10” x 15”, and 9” x 13”.
- These cookie sheets have nonstick inside and out, and they are designed to bake your cookies evenly.
- The rolled rims and the wide handles help you get a good grip so you can avoid messes, spills, and accidents when carrying these cookie sheets.
Cons:
- Although these cookie sheets are dishwasher safe, it is better if you wash them by hand.
8. Best Cookie Sheet with Silicone Handles: Gorilla Grip Non Stick Baking Pans
Last on our list is this set of cookie sheets that feature silicone handles to help make it easier for you to get a good grip. Think about it: a cookie sheet can be difficult to hold and carry when you’re wearing thick oven mitts and trying to avoid burns while taking it out of the oven. With silicone grips on the handles, you may find that you have more control so you can prevent accidents and messes more easily.
These cookie sheets are made of durable, high-quality carbon steel, and this is a material that can resist bending, warping, and popping when exposed to high oven temperatures. Plus, these are resistant to scratches and rust, and they have a nonstick coating on the surface to help make food release quick and easy.
Pros:
- These nonstick cookie sheets are made of carbon steel that helps prevent them from popping and bending.
- The silicone grips on the handles make it easy to carry these cookie sheets when you are wearing thick oven mitts.
- You can conveniently store these three cookie sheets without them taking up much space because they are stackable.
Cons:
- Some customer reviews have negative things to say about the quality of the silicone grips on these cookie sheets.
Things to look out for:
When shopping for cookie sheets, there are several things that are worth keeping in mind, as they can help you make the right decision regarding which product to go with. Here are some features that we recommend looking into:
To start, think about the size of the cookie sheet that you want to get. This can help you quickly narrow down your options, as there are products that come in sizes small, medium, and large. You can also consider buying a set of cookie sheets to get multiple sizes from one convenient purchase.
Another thing to consider is the material of the cookie sheet. Do you want something that is made of stainless steel, aluminum, or ceramic, as a few examples? Or perhaps you want to stick with nonstick cookie sheets to help prevent your cookies from sticking and causing a mess.
Yet another thing that you can consider is whether you want any accessories with your cookie sheets or if you want any special features. For example, you might want to go with a cookie sheet that comes with a matching cooling rack so you can save money by not needing to buy these products separately. Or, you might want to search for cookie sheets that have silicone grips on the handles to make it easier to transfer the sheet from your counter to your oven and back again.
Photo credit: JeniFoto/Shutterstock